Witch Bitch Thrift
Mystery Pants
Leaving it up to fate? Time for some Mystery Thrifting!
HOW IT WORKS:
☾ Pick your size and purchase your Mystery piece
Tag sizes are very arbitrary and unreliable. For this reason, we have sorted all our pieces by their measurements (instead of tag size).
Please reference our official size chart!
☾ Our team will pick you a piece in that size, and you won't see it until you receive your package in the mail (or pick up your order in store)
☾ Pictures are for illustration purposes. We cannot guarantee which piece you'll get.
☾ There will be no refunds or cancellations.
☾ There will be no swaps or replacements.
If you need any additional information on this item, click the "Chat" button below, followed by "Request more info about this item."
Couldn't load pickup availability
🧵 Sizing Info
Forget tag sizes — they’re inconsistent and all over the place.
At Witch Bitch Thrift, we measure everything by hand and list sizes based on actual garment measurements (like bust, waist, hips, and stretch).
That’s why a tag might say “XL” but we list it as a “1X” — it’s about fit, not factory labels.
We created our Universal Size Chart to help you find what truly fits — across brands, styles, and decades.
✨ Check your measurements + explore the chart here: WBT Size Chart
🔮 Fit Notes & Fabric Feel
We measure and assess each piece to provide details on condition, stretch, and pockets, helping you understand how it might fit and feel.
🛍 Shipping & Pickup
- Orders typically ship within 3–5 business days.
- Local to New Haven? Select free in-store pickup at checkout.
💌 Returns & Policies
All sales are final. We encourage you to thoroughly check all information provided for each product before making your purchase.
Please refer to our Info & Policies page for more details.
- Shop small, score big
- Measured by hand
- One of a Kind
