ATTENTION: YES, we are currently accepting buying drop offs!

Got some cool clothes, accessories, or other goods that might fit our vibe? Sell them to Witch Bitch Thrift!

How to drop your batch off:

Are you local to New Haven Connecticut? 

You can drop off your items during regular shop hours:

Tue 11 am - 6 pm
Wed 11 am - 6 pm
Thu 11 am - 6 pm
Fri 11 am - 7 pm
Sat 11 am - 7 pm
Sun 11 am - 6 pm

We are located at 105 Whitney Ave, New Haven CT 06510.

Once your items are dropped off, there is no need to check in with us for updates! 
The process can take 4 weeks at least, and a WBT representative will be in touch when your payout is ready, with no need to follow up. Please read the "how it works" section below for an in-depth play-by-play of what happens after drop off.

***** We do not have the bandwidth to respond to individual inquiries about pending drop-offs and we appreciate your patience! *****


Do you live farther away? 

WORRY NOT, we now have a PO Box you can ship your items to!

PO BOX 1386

In your box, please include a piece of paper with your name, phone number, and email address so that we may reach out to you.

After picking your package from the post office, it should take about 4 weeks+ to process your items, and we will follow up with you for next steps when we're done.

how it works:

Here's the play-by-play of your batch's journey through Witch Bitch Thrift:

🔸 You bring in your items to drop off to the front register of WBT
🔸 Someone from our team will hand you a Buying Check In form for you to fill out and sign. You can find a copy of the Buying Check In form here.
🔸 Once you fill out your form, an email confirmation will be sent to the email you provided, containing the same information on the form you signed off on
🔸 Your batch will then enter the buying queue! Once your batch reaches our buyer, all of your items will be priced and a tally of prices will be kept.
🔸 As your batch is priced, pieces are mixed in with our general inventory.
🔸 After your batch is priced, your tally will enter the calculation queue, where someone in our team reviews each buying sheet and calculates your cash and shop credit totals.
🔸 After your batch totals are calculated, your buying form is sent to the email queue - where someone in our team will email you, and provide your totals. You must respond to our email in order to receive your payout.
🔸 Once we receive your choice of payout, your batch will enter the payout queue and you'll receive either your cash or credit payout.

What's in it for me?

We do accept donations, but you can also choose between receiving store credit or cash for your items:

Cash: 10% of value
Credit: 15% of value

At the end of the process, we will not send you a detailed breakdown of each item, but instead a total amount for either cash or credit.

Unless arranged otherwise, all items that we pass on will be rehomed to where there is need in the community and not returned to you.

What we're into:

Modern or Vintage clothes
Graphic Tees
Button downs
Vintage lingerie
Small decor items
Interesting artifacts
Home Goods
Small furniture (upon approval)

What we're NOT into:

We are no longer accepting WINTER GEAR AND OUTERWEAR for the season.

Lingerie (excluding vintage pieces)
Big Furniture
Most formal gowns


other things to keep in mind:

🔸 Please be mindful of the condition of your items. We try to repair pieces as much as we can, but do not have the capacity to take any more repair projects at the moment. Make sure the pieces are clean, without any stains, holes, excessive pet fur, excessive stretching, or missing parts.

🔸 Once your items are priced and entered into your buying tally, they are mixed into our general inventory. By dropping off your items at WBT, you understand that after that point, we will be unable to retrieve or return your items to you.

🔸 Since pieces are mixed into the inventory as they are priced, you might see your piece on social media or on our website before you hear from us. But don't worry! You should receive an email shortly with your totals.

🔸 If you have a high quantity of items (like, barrels worth?) please call ahead of time to make sure we can accommodate your batch.

🔸 The process can take 4 weeks at least, and a WBT representative will be in touch when your payout is ready, with no need to follow up. We do not have the bandwidth to respond to individual inquiries about pending drop-offs and appreciate your patience!

🔸 By dropping off your items at WBT, you confirm that you have read and accepted our buying process & policies. If you have any questions, reach out to us through the form below.


Got questions? Reach out!

Value is required
Thank you!